December 13, 2019
Spindle Bar’s eggnog recipe
The staff at Optimist Hall’s cocktail hub prefers the classic
What’s the holiday season without a little eggnog? Stephanie Andrews, beverage director for Spindle Bar and upcoming cocktail bar Billy Sunday, shares a tried-and-true recipe for the indulgent winter treat. Too lazy to make your own? Homestead Creamery’s eggnog is available at Whole Foods, and tastes great warmed up with a little bourbon or rum mixed in. Andrews’ recipe is simple, however, and will last a while in the fridge. The sweetness and saltiness can be adjusted to taste, she says. —Kristen Wile
Spindle Bar’s Eggnog
Ingredients
6 eggs, separated
6 tbsp. white sugar
1 pinch of salt
8 oz. heavy cream
16 oz. whole milk
1 tsp. pure vanilla extract or 1 vanilla bean
4 to 6 oz. preferred alcohol (Andrews uses Elijah Craig bourbon and one ounce of Smith and Cross rum)
Grated nutmeg to taste
Directions
- In stand mixer or large bowl, whip egg whites until medium peaks.
- In the meantime (in another bowl), combine sugar, salt, and egg yolks, then beat until pale yellow and the sugar is dissolved.
- Add heavy cream and whole milk to the yolk mixture, whisking until combined. Then, whisk in vanilla and grated nutmeg.
- Fold whipped egg whites into the yolk mixture until combined. Stir in preferred booze.
- To serve, pour into a glass and top with freshly grated nutmeg.






